Feed Articles Screener

Expensive oil was supposed to sink them; these 3 cruise lines instead report records and expect further growth

Oil this year soared to $138 per barrel, and cruise ships, which burn hundreds of thousands of tons of it annually, were supposed to be the first to suffer. Instead, all three largest cruise operators raised their profit outlooks, yet for a dollar of profit the market pays almost twice as much for one of them as for another.

Key points

  • Oil in April soared to $138 per barrel, yet all three largest cruise operators raised their profit outlooks.

  • For a dollar of profit the market pays 18.8 dollars for one of these companies, and less than ten for another.

  • Two autumn bond issues, one at 5.55% and the other at 8.75%, explain the difference better than results.

  • The sector's cheapest stock carries net debt of 14.8 billion dollars and negative free cash flow over the last 12 months.

  • Three specific dates between December and the beginning of March will decide which discount is real.

Same sea, three completely different price tags

This year was supposed to sink cruise lines. The closed Strait of Hormuz in April drove Brent crude prices up to $138 per barrel, and ships burning hundreds of thousands of tons of fuel annually were among the first victims on the stock exchange. But in autumn, something few expected happened: all three largest companies in the industry raised their full-year profit outlook, and as Brent fell back to $92, their shares over the last month rose by 9.5% to 18%.

At first glance, then, one sector, one piece of good news. But looking at the price tags, the picture falls apart. For one dollar of profit you pay 18.8 dollars for Royal Caribbean $RCL, 12.4 for Carnival $CCL, and less than ten for Norwegian Cruise Line $NCLH.

Company

Price

Annual high

From high

P/E

Year over year

Royal Caribbean

320.65 USD

356.39 USD

-10.0%

18.8

+25.3%

Carnival

28.97 USD

34.03 USD

-14.9%

12.4

+11.1%

Norwegian

17.99 USD

25.13 USD

-28.4%

9.9

+1.2%

Same sea, same customers, same oil. So why does the market value one company as a growth story and another as a sell-off? Two bond issues from this autumn best explain it: one at 5.55% and the other at 8.75%.

Royal Caribbean: what the highest price in the sector pays for

Royal Caribbean earned 6.57 dollars per share in the third quarter on revenue of 5.6 billion dollars, up 9% year over year and above its own outlook. It raised its full-year outlook to 17.85 to 17.95 dollars per share, which is more important than it looks: the midpoint of 17.90 dollars is exactly what the company promised in January, before the oil shock. Higher demand completely absorbed more expensive fuel.

Bookings for 2027 since the last call with analysts are growing by nearly 20% at higher prices, and management maintains its target of earning over 20 dollars per share next year. It is also buying half of the Caribbean resort network Sandals and borrowed 1.25 billion dollars in the third quarter on bonds at 5.55%, the cheapest in the industry.

"I understand there was a lot of noise in the market this year. There is a lot of geopolitics, but when I look at our business: our original outlook for this year had a midpoint of 17.90 dollars. The midpoint of our current outlook is 17.90 dollars."

Jason Liberty, Chairman and CEO of Royal Caribbean Group

But that reliability comes at a price. P/E of 18.8 is above the industry average (16.8) and Bulios fair value of 260 dollars lies 19% below the market. The stock is priced on higher cruise prices holding into 2027, so any hesitation in pricing costs the most here.

Carnival: half the price and half of 2027 already sold

Carnival reported record net income of 1.9 billion dollars for its fiscal third quarter and raised its full-year outlook to 2.24 dollars per share. Customers hold a record 7.6 billion dollars in deposits for future cruises, and the company's CEO Josh Weinstein said on the earnings call that 2027 is already half booked at record occupancy and prices.

"For the full year 2027, booked occupancy and prices are at record levels, giving a solid foundation for another year of solid revenue growth. And looking further ahead, 2028 is also off to an excellent start, with higher occupancy and prices than last year."

Josh Weinstein, CEO of Carnival Corporation

But the most important shift is on the balance sheet. Debt, which peaked at 36 billion dollars in 2023, fell below 24 billion; the company in the summer early repaid 500 million dollars of seven-percent bonds and obtained a second investment grade rating. It also bought back 1.2 billion dollars in shares this year. All at a P/E of 12.4 and a free cash flow yield of 8.2%; Bulios fair value is 38.97 dollars, a third higher than where the stock trades.

The catch: the spring booking disruption, according to Weinstein, spilled into the first quarter of 2027; the new loyalty program dampens reported revenue accounting-wise, and ordered new ships, the first arriving in 2029, will again raise investment. The first test comes with full fiscal year results around December 18.

Norwegian: the cheapest stock has the most expensive debt

A multiple of less than ten times earnings looks like a sell-off, but at 17.99 dollars you are buying earnings that are set to decline next year. Norwegian raised its outlook to 1.70 dollars per share, but yield per passenger cruise day is down 4.4% this year, it expects an adjusted loss of 0.12 dollars per share in the fourth quarter, and analyst consensus for 2027 is 1.40 dollars, lower than this year. The company itself writes that its bookings remain "below the optimal range" and the first half of 2027 is booked worse than at this time last year.

"Even though in the first half of the year we are behind the booking curve, which we said very clearly, when you look at the second half, where we are on the curve, and our new pre-sale strategy, we can likely improve from there. I certainly would not say we are at an optimal point."

John Chidsey, Chairman and CEO of Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings

Then there is the debt. Net debt of 14.8 billion dollars is 5.5 times EBITDA, almost double what Royal Caribbean carries, and free cash flow over the last 12 months is negative (-531 million dollars). When Norwegian borrowed 950 million dollars in October, it paid 8.75% annually, more than three percentage points above its competitor. Moreover, CFO Mark Kempa is stepping down at the end of the year after over 25 years with the company.

The company has savings of over 600 million dollars, a new water park on its private island Great Stirrup Cay, and a promise that prices in 2027 will grow by 1 to 2%. Bulios fair value of 24.35 dollars is 35% above the market, but the discount is real only if the turnaround actually arrives.

What will decide: three dates and one price per barrel

  • December 18, Carnival: results for the full fiscal year. Watch whether 2027 occupancy keeps rising and debt keeps falling even after billions in buybacks. If so, twelve times earnings is the most understandable discount in the sector.

  • February 4, 2027, Royal Caribbean: the first full-year outlook for 2027. Will it confirm twenty dollars per share or not? Anything below means the 18.8 times premium is built on water.

  • March 1, 2027, Norwegian: how the so-called wave season, the January to March period when most cruises are sold, turned out. If the first half of 2027 does not fill in, "ten times" on lower earnings will turn into a higher multiple without the stock rising.

  • Oil: Brent below 90 dollars helps everyone, above 100 hurts Norwegian the most. Royal Caribbean has 53% of 2027 consumption hedged at 405 dollars per ton, Norwegian 42% at 559 dollars.

So there are three scenarios. If cruise prices hold, Royal Caribbean will defend its premium and Carnival will chase it with the least risk. If Norwegian manages the turnaround, it offers the biggest percentage move in the sector. And if bookings do not accelerate in January, the cheapest stock will remain cheap for a good reason.

Before your next step

No single piece of content is a reason to buy or sell. Investors on Bulios decide based on their own analysis. Our academy teaches you how, step by step.

Open the academy How Bulios content is made is described by our editorial standards.

Follow Bulios on Google News

Be among the first to discover new analyses, news and market moves.

Follow

Recommended articles

Read more
BLACK

Dividends Above 10%? No Problem for These Stocks

A yield of over 15% a year sounds almost unbelievable in the stock market, yet several established US-listed securities are offering just that today. Mortgage REITs and leveraged bond funds earn money from the difference between the yield on mortgages or bonds and the cost of short-term financing,…

KJ
Kryštof Jáně
· 10h
Read more

These 3 Stocks Raised Their Dividends During the 2008 Crisis and COVID. One Pays Every Month

When companies were canceling shareholder payouts in 2009 and again during the pandemic, these three railway companies were raising them instead. Today they offer yields of 2.1% to 5.7% a year.

MC
Milan Charvat
· 1d
Read more
BLACK

Up 30% since the start of the year and outperforming tech

2026 was supposed to belong to artificial intelligence, semiconductors and another record year for technology indexes. Instead, the best returns are hiding where most investors haven't looked for years. Oil, soft drinks, medicine and a bank. Five large, long-overlooked companies have gained between…

KJ
Kryštof Jáně
· 1d

We use essential cookies to run the website and optional analytics cookies to measure usage.

Privacy policy